Carnival Fever, Soca, Calypso, J'ouvert, Mas, Costume, Fete, TnT

Your only destination to all things CARNIVAL

Real,True, Not-Fake Carnival History—CANBOULAY

So: a group of armed thugs organise themselves, attack the police, and create chaos because the police stopped them from breaking the law the previous year. The police are held back, and the thugs get off “scotch” free. Then, 122 years later, the act is celebrated as heroism, which some very disturbed people say should be “taught in schools.” (Not to worry: as violence and attacking police go, schools are ahead of the game.)


I refer, of course, to the Canboulay Riots of 1881, which are re-enacted on Piccadilly Street every year before Carnival. It is, say its stagers, the central rite of the Carnival. (Amazing how random people can just pronounce things “central rites” and nobody says nutten, like, “Stop talking that dotishness, nuh.”)


I’m curious. How is a group of thugs attacking police in the streets in 1881 different from a group of thugs in Islamic costume attacking the Parliament in 1990 because they were enraged by the Government? Answer: it’s no different. And, like the Canboulay rioters, some people see the 1990 thugs as heroes, and try to emulate them. Every day.


The perverse re-staging and re-framing of Canboulay introduces an aspect of the study of history unknown to many consumers (and many UWI historians): historiography. This is how history is written, its sources validated, and its narratives interpreted. All this implicates the social, ethnic and emotional logic of the historian and the institutions which authorise him/her.


If the historian/consumer is ethnically obsessed, not very bright, not honest, and emotionally deficient, it leads to a perverse understanding of history, and a confused society. 



A clear assessment of the Canboulay riots was provided by the Secretary of State for the Colonies, the Earl of Kimberley: “The governor acted wisely in the crisis in himself calming the mob, but this exhibition of the head of the government begging a riotous mob to desist from violence, if repeated, would destroy the authority of the government, and a mob which has felt its power may not confine itself to Carnival time.”


It wasn’t a mistake the colonial Government repeated. They opened fire on the Hosay rioters in 1884, and the water rioters in 1903. (Even the colonial Government understood the labour marches of 1937 were not criminal but legitimate protests.) Once the evil colonial master departed, the natives botched it. In 1970, they didn’t shoot the army insurgents and in 1990 they didn’t shoot the Muslimeen. The result? Look around. If only we’d listened to the evil white master.


Over the last two weeks, I’ve proposed how Carnival, nationalism, and ethnicity became intertwined in the idea of the newly independent T&T during the 1960s. One consequence of that fusion is a particular way of understanding reality, which, over time, has generated strong dystopian social attitudes, beliefs and practices, which have never been challenged.


A good example is the axiom that “de grassroots” (the criminal, the illiterate, the oppressed) position is always morally superior to the official position found in schoolbooks, law courts, and conventional art and morality. Hence, teach calypso and Canboulay in schools, but not reading and writing.


The major works which seek to establish Carnival as a “national tradition” avail themselves of this assumption—that morality is somehow intrinsic to the lower orders, and absent from the upper. The most authoritative of these works include John Cowley’s Carnival, Canboulay and Calypso, Hollis Liverpool’s Rituals of Power & Rebellion, Milla Riggio’s (edited) collection, Culture in Action.



This notion flourished post-independence, since the institutions designed to inculcate morals, civic values, social cohesiveness and so on were slowly strangled. The last, weak gasp of the moral and social possibilities from pre-independence was the NAR.


With an increasingly attenuated ability to counter Carnival nationalism over the last 50 years, its complex of beliefs and practices seeped into public culture, education, and civic consciousness. Its values are visible in the ubiquitous misanthropy, corruption, malignant libidinousness which is taken for pleasure, narcissism which passes for self-esteem, infantile emotionalism which passes for patriotism, consumerist carnality which passes for mas. These traits are all visible in the Canboulay re-enactment.


Given all this, the question arises: Does history provide an alternative to the Carnival delusion as a source of values and ideas? Ironically, an alternative sits 50 metres away from the Canboulay re-enactment: the Lodge United Brothers temple. It is the first and oldest masonic lodge in Trinidad.  



Freemasonry has been in the Caribbean for centuries and in Trinidad since the late 18th century. The vast majority of Trinidadian men of importance (except Eric Williams), from JJ Thomas to HOB Wooding (and including MM Philip, CP David, FEM Hosein, Patrick Solomon) were Freemasons.


Superstitions abound about freemasonry, and it was, like everything else, susceptible to corruption. However, its values were, and are, public service, respect for knowledge, and the brotherhood of all men. Black, white and Indian men fraternised in masonic lodges from c1900.



In addition, there were many friendly societies and fraternal associations with the same objectives, like the Oddfellows, Mechanics, and Gardeners. The lodges bridged class and race divides and had the potential to bring a fractured society together from the top and middle through meaningful rituals, shared knowledge, and consensus about the common good and how to achieve it.


Unfortunately, UWI knows exactly nothing about this, and you won’t find this in any textbook or historical works claiming to explore traditions or cultural history. What you will find is a lot of sloppy, insupportable ethnocentric nonsense. The final question is: how do they get away with it? It has everything to do with those tourists we supposedly love so much.

Views: 115


You need to be a member of Carnival Fever, Soca, Calypso, J'ouvert, Mas, Costume, Fete, TnT to add comments!

Join Carnival Fever, Soca, Calypso, J'ouvert, Mas, Costume, Fete, TnT

Comment by mcmoutlet on July 2, 2015 at 1:40am

It was converse outlet in the moment of turning away prada outlet that I somehow learned, without looking, that coach outlet Mrs. Brissenden had also immediately moved. I nike air max wanted to look and yet had my reasons for not appearing to do it baseball bats too quickly; new balance in spite louboutin,louboutin outlet,louboutin outlet italia of which I found burberry my longchamp friends, even after an hollister interval, still distinguishable as separating for oakley sunglasses the avoidance replica watches of comment. Gilbert ralph lauren uk Long, rising directly after his associate, had iphone 6 cases already insanity workout walked mont blanc away, but this associate, lingering wedding dresses where longchamp outlet she stood and swarovski crystal meeting me hollister with it, availed herself of the occasion to swarovski show that she wished to nike air max speak to me. Such was the juicy couture outlet idea juicy couture outlet she threw out on my forthwith going to michael kors her. “For north face outlet a nike blazer few minutes — presently.”She hesitated long enough montre pas cher for me to judge supra shoes her as a trifle surprised at ferragamo shoes my being so ready — as if pandora jewelry indeed she had ray ban sunglasses rather hoped karen millen I wouldn’t michael kors outlet be; nike roshe run which would have michael kors outlet been nike air max an easy pretext to hollister her true religion outlet to gain babyliss time. jordan shoes In fact, with a mulberry face not quite like the brave michael kors outlet face she had at each step hitherto shown me, yet unlike in a fashion vans pas cher I should certainly not ralph lauren have been able thomas sabo to define on the spot; with polo ralph lauren outlet an expression, in short, that pandora charms struck me as oakley sunglasses taking refuge in gucci outlet a general reminder that not my coach outlet convenience, but her nike free run uk own, was in question, she replied: “Oh, no north face outlet — but before it’s longchamp too late. A few minutes hence. Where shall you be?” she north face asked with a burberry outlet online shade, as I imagined, of polo ralph lauren outlet awkwardness. She had burberry looked about as for symptoms of acceptance of the evening’s end on nike trainers the part toms shoes of the ladies, chi flat iron but replica watches we nfl jerseys could both see our hostess otherwise ray ban uk occupied. kate spade handbags “We don’t go up quite yet. In soccer jerseys the morning,” she oakley sunglasses added as with an afterthought, “I suppose you coach factory outlet leave early.”She looked nike air max at me nike air max straighter now. “I haven’t louboutin thought either.” Then she hollister was silent, neither turning away nor coming polo lacoste pas cher to the point, prada handbags as it seemed to lancel me she might sac guess have done, of christian louboutin outlet telling me what she had in her head. I hollister,abercrombie,hollister sito ufficiale,abercrombie italia,abercrombie and fitch,abercrombie outlet even chanel handbags fancied that her vanessa bruno momentary silence, combined vans shoes with the valentino shoes way she faced me — as michael kors outlet if that might speak bottega veneta for her — was sac longchamp meant for timberland boots an assurance true religion jeans that, whatever train she should take in the morning, michael kors she would arrange that it nike free shouldn’t be, converse,scarpe converse,converse italia,converse sito ufficiale,converse all star as it had been the day before, the same as gucci,borse gucci,gucci sito ufficiale,gucci outlet mine. I really true religion jeans caught in her attitude louboutin a world michael kors of new balance pas cher invidious air force reference to the jimmy choo shoes little journey birkin bag we had already made together. She true religion jeans had sympathies, she had proprieties that imposed themselves, vans,vans scarpe,vans italia and lululemon I ghd was air jordan pas cher not to tiffany and co think that any little journey was to be thought of again in those conditions. It came over me mcm handbags that this might michael kors have giuseppe zanotti been quite a matter discussed by her, asics running shoes discussed and settled, with her ray ban pas cher interlocutor on the sofa. It came over timberland me that if, before our ray ban sunglasses break-up for ralph lauren,polo ralph lauren,ralph lauren outlet,ralph lauren italia,ralph lauren sito ufficiale the night, I herve leger should happen also to have a minute’s talk oakley,occhiali oakley,oakley italia with that interlocutor, converse pas cher I would equally get from it the celine handbags sense of an intention unfavourable to our departing in the p90x workout same lululemon group. beats by dre And I wondered coach outlet if this, in kate spade outlet that case, mac cosmetics wouldn’t air max,nike air max affect me as marking sac longchamp a air max change back to Long’s old manner — a forfeiture of the hollister pas cher conditions, whatever view might be taken of nike huarache,nike huaraches,nike air huarache them, that had made him, ray ban,rayban,occhiali ray ban at Paddington, suddenly soccer shoes show himself as oakley pas cher so possible and so pleasant. If he “changed back,” wouldn’t Grace michael kors outlet Brissenden change by instyler the same law? And if Grace Brissenden did, nike free wouldn’t her husband? Wouldn’t the miracle take tn pas cher the form of the rejuvenation of that husband? Would it, still by the same hermes token, take the form of her becoming very wedding dresses old, becoming reebok shoes if not abercrombie and fitch as old air max as her husband, at least as old, as one might louboutin shoes say, as links of london herself? Would it louboutin outlet take the form of her becoming dreadfully plain — plain with the plainness marc jacobs of mere stout maturity and longchamp outlet artificial preservation? And if it took this form pandora charms for the nike roshe others, abercrombie and fitch which tiffany and co jewelry would it take for May Server? north face Would hogan she, tory burch outlet at nike outlet a bound coach purses as marked as theirs, recover her presence of mind nike roshe and her lost equipment?

© 2020   Created by omar.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service